Wouldn't this require new laws to be passed by the
county or the state?
No. A number of cities and counties across
the country are using their state's "Theft of Services" law
to prosecute employers who deliberately commit wage theft. Tennessee has a theft
of services law that could be used for this purpose by Shelby County, if the
Sheriff and
District Attorney's Departments agreed to do so.
How would criminalizing wage theft affect businesses?
Business
that are following the law and paying their workers correctly will have nothing
to worry about.
In fact, recognizing wage theft as a crime can
actually help these businesses. Right now,
many responsible businesspeople are
being undercut by unscrupulous employers who break the law.
They can charge
lower prices because they make money off the stolen wages they take from their
workers.
Recognizing wage theft as a crime will level the playing
field for responsible businesses.
Would an employer be arrested right away if they didn't pay their
workers?
No. Workers will have to demonstrate that the employer intentionally did not pay
them, rather than by
accident.
This could be proven in a variety of ways, from the employer scheduling a pay
day and
failing to show up, to bouncing a check and failing to make
payment in a reasonable amount of time
after the employer has been informed that
the check bounced.
Workers Interfaith Network is
also proposing that employers who violate the law be warned by the Sheriff's
Department that an arrest
warrant will be issued if they do not pay the worker(s) within a specified period of time.
Can't the Department of Labor take care of this problem?
There are many things the Department of Labor can and should do, but they can't
solve
the problem by themselves. Currently, the legal options that workers can exercise in response
to wage theft
are to either file a complaint with the U.S. Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour
Division,
or to file a civil court charge against an employer. Clearly, low-wage
workers who have experienced
the theft of their wages are not in a
position to pay court fees and hire a lawyer.
The US Department
of Labor's Wage and Hour Division is only permitted to investigate
nonpayment of
wages in cases that involve interstate commerce, or where annual
sales are over $500,000.
This does not apply to many of the businesses that are
committing wage theft in Memphis, especially
small construction and landscaping
operations. Local law enforcement is ideally suited for these types of
wage theft cases. Workers Interfaith Network also believes that the stigma of a potential arrest
will deter many employers from committing wage theft in the first place.